Choralgirl tagged me for a fabulous meme: identify hymns that have shaped, or which reveal, my theology. She puts it so perfectly that I'll just quote her thoughts here:
Selecting a hymn for my community to sing can happen for so many reasons...because it fits with the texts; because it fits the liturgical season; because it fits our particular context at the moment; because they love it or because it will challenge them; because it's theologically sound; because we need to remember that "me and Jesus" isn't the whole story, or because we need to remember that Jesus loves each of us intimately; because it has a tune that will live in their hearts and embed the text in their consciousness; because it prays; because it praises; because it laments; because it thanks; because it celebrates the gifts all around and within us.
It drives me nuts when the conversation is reduced to "I like (or, often, don't like) that one," or "Hey, that was catchy." That's too impoverished, too auto-pilot. It misses out on the richness.
And so, I got to thinking. If I could choose ten hymns that together have truly shaped me, that speak to me, that comprise my theology, what would they be?
Oh, this was fun. And a fabulous Thursday break from the sermon, which is stuck about halfway through (not bad for a Thursday). I tried to keep it to ten, but I ended up with eleven. Here goes.
1. Lift High the Cross (Crucifer)
This was always my favorite hymn as a child. And then my parents went and ruined it by choosing it for my grandfather's funeral, which happened when I was 14. For years after that, I tried to avoid singing it, because I assumed that once you associate a hymn with a death, you've ruined the hymn. This turns out not to be the case (although it is tough to sing it for awhile, for sure). Instead, that memory enriched the hymn and the hymn itself enriched my memories of my grandfather. Like many hymns, the lyrics have some trouble spots - a bit more military imagery than I'd prefer these days. And yet...
Praise to the Crucified for victory!
It is, after all, lift high the cross - not lift high the power, or glory, or mighty outstretched arm. My own deep love for Luther's theology of the cross might well have started here.
And, on a personal note, it developed into such a meaningful hymn for me that we chose this as the processional hymn for our wedding. As it should be: crucifer first, then everyone else. (Clarifying note: the clip below is not from our wedding. Just thought you should know.)
2. The Church's One Foundation (Aurelia)
I chose this one because we sang it at Current Congregation last Sunday, and then got into a big discussion the following Tuesday about whether the words are truly horrible or not. Problems: kinda sexist ("She is his new creation"). And kinda elitist ("elect from every nation"). But you know what? I still love this hymn, and I even love its old-school words. I could do without the girl-church metaphor, but I have to admit that I didn't hear the same elitism that others did. To me, this hymn speaks about the church's unity, and its struggles, and its hopes.
And soon the night of weeping shall be the morn of song.
I love the reminder that the church is not about me, and I am not the whole church - and we, in this sanctuary, are and yet are not the whole church - and we have a fractured, bitter, sometimes-ugly history, and yet...there is hope to come.
3. Rise, Shine You People (Wojtkiewiecz) (holy mackerel, what a tune title.)
Some songs I love because of the tune, or because of the whole experience. And some have one perfect line or phrase which shapes and reveals my theology. I love this one for the music. But most of all, I love this one for this line:
Our human story; God in him is centered
There's my Trinitarian doctrine in five words: "God in him is centered." Do I know completely what that means? No. Do I need to? No. Does it say all I can, so far, figure out about the Trinity? You bet.
4. Will You Let Me Be Your Servant (The Servant Song)
Some songs shape your thinking about your relationship to God, and some shape your thinking about your relationships to one another. This one so perfectly encapsulates the church's greatest gift and its greatest dilemma:
let me be as Christ to you?
Pray that I may have the grace to
let you be my servant too.
Servants to one another. Sometimes the servant, sometimes the served. Both require such grace. Both can be so hard. And so hopeful.
This was our post-sermon wedding hymn, by the way.
5. Have No Fear Little Flock (Little Flock)
This one I remember from childhood. I associate it with lots of good kid-church memories. And also with my current love for preaching and teaching that first phrase: "have no fear." I was afraid of the dark as a kid. And I don't know that I ever sang this hymn to myself at night, but I do know that hymns like this shaped my childhood faith in such a way that I learned that the fear of God is not the same as being afraid of God. Our world runs largely on fear. I hope that the church can be a sign of a different way.
6. Of the Father's Love Begotten (Divinum Mysterium)
Gorgeous tune. Amazing words.
Ere the worlds began to be
He is Alpha and Omega
He the source, the ending he
Of the things that are, that have been
And that future years shall see,
Evermore and evermore.
Such a vision of the wholeness, the breadth of God's love for us and for the world. Amen.
The clip below is a song called, "Hope for Resolution," which intertwines this hymn with an African tune. It's a six minute clip, but believe me: it will be among the best six minutes of your day. Crank it up.
7. Listen! You Nations
I'm not sure if any non-Lutherans will know this one: it's a canticle from the Lutheran Book of Worship. We used to sing these regularly in church when I was young. And this one I especially loved as a kid because of this verse:
Like a garden refreshed by the rain, they will never be in want again.
There aren't a lot of hymns in which "young women" can find themselves described. This one gets at a bit of the diversity of God's people, and it's chock full of joy.
8. Canticle of the Turning (Star of County Down)
I always have to get past my initial "aargh, matey, it's a grand old hymn" feeling about this one. It's a bit pirate-y. But man, the words ROCK.
that the God of my heart is great,
and my spirit sings of the wondrous things
that you bring to the ones who wait.
You fixed your sight on your servant's plight,
and my weakness you did not spurn,
so from east to west shall my name be blest.
Could the world be about to turn?
My heart shall sing of the day you bring.
Let the fires of your justice burn.
Wipe away all tears, for the dawn draws near,
and the world is about to turn.
Oh, it's too good for just one verse. One more.
not a stone will be left on stone.
Let the king beware for your justice tears
every tyrant from his throne.
The hungry poor shall weep no more,
for the food they can never earn;
there are tables spread, ev'ry mouth be fed,
for the world is about to turn.
God turns everything upside down. For personal reference, see: every sermon I have ever preached. Pretty much.
9. O Sacred Head Now Wounded (Herzlich Tut Mich Verlangen)
No good Lutheran can complete this list without some kind of Bach reference, and a hymn sung during Lent.
The words are good. But what I love best about this hymn is that it's in a minor key. That's theology of the cross in musical form: sometimes life happens in the minor key. Or, as Barbara Brown Taylor has put it, "you can never fall further than God can catch you. Sadly, you cannot always be specific about where the catch will be. Sometimes it comes on the other side of the grave." Easter is coming, and you can't forget that when you sing this hymn. But sometimes we all need to walk out of the room with the minor key ringing in our ears. That's life.
10. We are Baptized in Christ Jesus (Ouimette)
Also a newer one. Theologically, two big high points: that the title is, "We Are Baptized," not, "We Were Baptized." Important distinction. Baptism is a way of life.
And two: the second verse.
in the breaking of the bread,
in the waiting arms of Jesus
who is risen from the dead,
God has made a new beginning
from the ashes of our past;
in the losing and the winning
we hold fast.
And, finally...
11. Joyous Light of Heavenly Glory (Joyous Light)
Because if I could only sing one liturgy for the rest of my life, Holden Evening Prayer would be the one. Because it makes me cry every time. And because I can imagine no greater joy in heaven than singing this with every person I have ever loved.
loving glow of God's own face,
you who sing creation's story,
shine on every land and race.
Now as evening falls around us,
we shall raise our songs to you.
God of daybreak, God of shadows,
come and light our hearts anew.
In the stars that grace the darkness,
in the blazing sun of dawn,
in the light of peace and wisdom,
we can hear your quiet song.
Love that fills the night with wonder,
love that warms the weary soul,
love that bursts all chains asunder,
set us free and make us whole.
You who made the heaven's splendor,
ev'ry dancing star of night,
make us shine with gentle justice,
let us each reflect your light.
Mighty God of all creation,
gentle Christ who lights our way,
loving Spirit of salvation,
lead us on to endless day.








